Guffey's

4.1 (133 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in
+(14)

About Guffey's

Welcome to Guffey's, a delightful eatery located at 1451 High St #211 in Washington, MO. This vibrant establishment offers a diverse menu that transcends the typical pizza joint, showcasing flavorful dishes like their renowned dry-rub wings, decadent smoked gouda mac & cheese bites, and an assortment of artisan pizzas that promise to impress. The staff is recognized for their exceptional service, making dining here a pleasant experience. Whether you're stopping in for lunch, dinner, or catering for a special event, Guffey's ensures a lively atmosphere and a memorable culinary adventure that keeps patrons returning for more.

Reviews (133) 4.1

  • Samuel Sexton
    Jul 22,2025

    First time rollin in here with my mother, and we were definitely blown away by the food and by how nice the staff was; appetizers were the dry rub wings, seasoned fries and smoked gouda mac & cheese bites, with the loaded cheeseburger pizza - to say that this place is just a "pizza joint & bar" would do this place an injustice. Their food is absolutely popping with flavor, especially their pizza! Definitely would give David Portnoy a run for his money with his pizza reviews! Their dry-rub wings are tossed in a homemade seasoning (a state secret from what I was told) and they were absolutely amazing! If you are ever in this neck of the woods in Washington, definitely stop in for lunch or dinner - they even bake their own bread too! I'll definitely be returning in the future & will be recommending this restaurant to my friends and coworkers.

  • Paula Pruessner
    Jul 22,2025

    Love the pizza and dry rub wings! Great experience dining in and excellent results with carry out. The help is always on point with superior service. They catered for a group I was part of and everyone agreed it was A+ all the way. Christine’s was willing to work with every request I made, making a great event for us!!

  • Kathy Durham
    Jul 22,2025

    Great food. Super friendly staff. Fast service! Holds large amount of people, great for parties, not a "quiet type of atmosphere".

  • Jenna March
    Jul 22,2025

    I had such high hopes for Guffey's, and I was left so disappointed. The salads arrived quickly and were fresh and delicious, but that's where the positives ended. It took about 40 minutes to get some of our pizzas, with only one other table dining in. We kept waiting and waiting for our daughter's pizza to arrive and I had to go and find the waitress to ask her if we were still going to get the rest of our order. Apparently the system had removed her pizza from the order???? So now we were all finished eating and had to wait for them to start a pizza for my daughter. We were there an hour before she got her food. My husband ordered a turkey melt and the turkey was cold inside, which left a lot to be desired. We had to hunt down the waitress yet again to get boxes for our leftovers. We ordered cookies to go, which also took 20 minutes to bake, so I'm glad we got them ordered early. They look suuuuuper undercooked. The pizza is comparable to Imo's, so I'm not sure if I'll be giving Guffey's a second chance. Our experience left a lot to be desired, sadly.

  • Joe Zoellner
    Jul 22,2025

    We've ordered wings and pizza here 4 times now and are still chasing that first good experience. They have consistently disappointed on the quality of their wings. They tend to be overcooked and are usually pretty small. The pizza is good, but not fantastic. The last time we were there, we ordered a margarita. It has some sort of orange juice in it. Just not what we were looking for.

  • Brandy Jensen
    Jul 22,2025

    Absolutely delicious! We had gluten free boneless buffalo wings, pepperoni pizza bread, fried mushrooms, and a meatlovers pizza with black olives and mushrooms added. Constant drink refills, awesome service. We will be back FOR SURE!

  • Joshua Crocker
    Jul 22,2025

    Ordered a couple pizzas and apps. The pizza and apps were great and the kids loved the garlic parm bites. Service was fantastic and plenty to watch on the tvs in there. Nice atmosphere and great drink selection with a accommodating staff. We'll definitely be going back

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Guffey's?

    Guffey's is known for its delicious pizza, dry rub wings, and unique appetizers like smoked gouda mac & cheese bites. Many customers rave about the flavor and quality of the food!

  • Can I make a reservation at Guffey's?

    Yes, Guffey's accepts reservations, making it easier for larger groups to ensure they have a table.

  • Is Guffey's good for takeout?

    Absolutely! Guffey's offers takeout service, and many customers have had great experiences with their carry-out orders.

  • What is the atmosphere like at Guffey's?

    Guffey's offers a casual and cozy atmosphere that's great for groups. It's a lively place, so it may not be the best option for those seeking quiet dining.

  • What amenities does Guffey's provide for guests?

    Guffey's offers free parking, wheelchair accessibility, and accepts various payment methods including credit and debit cards. It's also kid-friendly with a kids' menu and high chairs available.

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
Benito's Inc

116 Elm St, Washington, MO 63090, United States

Pizza restaurant
Saucy’s Pizzeria Krakow

3021 Hwy A, Washington, MO 63090, United States

Pizza restaurant
Andy's Pizza Navy Yard at Atlas Brew Works

1201 Half St SE suite 120, Washington, DC 20003, United States

Pizza restaurant
Passato Pizza & Grill

2455 18th St NW, Washington, DC 20009, United States

Pizza restaurant
Bobe's Pizza Express

470 IN-57, Washington, IN 47501, United States

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page